Order this Assignment Now: £299
(b) Explain what evidence suggests that the control of the risks of legionella may not be adequate.
2026-11-11T15:37:00+00:00
DO – CONTROLLING WORKPLACE HEALTH ISSUES
Identifying weaknesses in Legionella prevention requires more than confirming that spa pool water is routinely sampled. The assessment examines whether monitoring results, disinfectant effectiveness, pH management and maintenance practices provide sufficient assurance that biological hazards are controlled at Waves and Weights (WW). Particular attention must be given to evidence indicating gaps between established procedures and actual operating conditions, without assuming that testing alone guarantees safety. Academia Support UK provides complete, scenario-based NEBOSH answers with focused explanations drawn from the scenario and supporting spa pool operational information.
UNIT DI2 / DN2 For: NEBOSH Level 6 Diploma for Occupational Health and Safety Management Professionals Preparing for your NEBOSH assessment interview? Explore our NEBOSH interview preparation support
SCENARIO
Waves and Weights (WW) is a leisure centre. It offers a swimming pool, gym, group workout sessions, a sauna, and a spa pool. It is located in a deprived part of a town, in an old run-down building. As it is the only leisure centre in the town, it is very busy and popular among local residents, and there is currently a waiting list for membership. Children’s swimming lessons are offered at the pool, which also has spa facilities. Sometimes, members using the spa are frustrated by the noise caused by the swimming lessons. The leisure centre consists of an entrance area, where the paint is peeling off the walls and what was once a bright yellow colour has now turned grey. Within the entrance area, there is a reception desk, a small café with seating, a small children’s play area, and a shop. In the reception area, the fluorescent strip lighting has been flashing on and off for a few weeks now; despite members complaining, this has not been fixed yet. The café recently obtained a licence to serve alcohol and has been offering a small menu of alcoholic drinks that members can purchase in the evening. From the entrance area there are doors that lead to separate male and female, wet (changing for swimming) and dry (changing for other activities) changing rooms, a gym, a large sports hall, and a group exercise room.
There are automatic barriers at the entrance to the leisure centre that open when either the user scans a membership card, or the receptionist opens them using the override button. The receptionist has the ability to leave the barriers open at busy times. Behind the reception desk, there is a doorway with a corridor leading to two small offices, where the duty managers are based. Along with the offices, there is a break room for workers. In the break room, fresh fruit is provided, and there are facilities to make hot drinks and heat up food. There is also a large water cooler with cups provided, a small seating area, and ten lockers. On the lockers, there are advertisements for the latest health promotion, a ‘stop smoking’ campaign. There is also a poster asking for volunteers to become mental health first-aiders. The poster is curled and ripped as it has been up for several weeks. Nothing further has been done about recruiting mental health first-aiders. Along the corridor, just outside the break room, there are toilets and a shower room for the workers.
GET FULL ANSWER HERE
The swimming pool, sauna, and spa pool are accessible through the wet changing rooms. There is a plant room accessed through a door in the pool area. This is where the operating equipment for the pools is located, along with some of the chemicals needed to manage pool water quality. Next to the plant room, there is a separate locked storeroom, where other chemicals for the pools are kept.
There are 35 full-time workers at WW and 25 part-time workers. The general manager works 09:00 - 17:00 and has overall responsibility for WW. Many workers work on a two-shift system. The early shift is from 06:00 to 14:15, and the late shift runs from 13:45 to 22:00. On each shift there is a duty manager, a receptionist, and a duty supervisor. Each of the duty supervisors has a team of six leisure assistants. The assistant’s role is to make sure that the large sports hall and group exercise room are set up with the correct equipment for the planned activities. This includes children’s parties, that are bookable for the weekends. The part-time workers include group exercise instructors, swimming teachers, café workers, and cleaners.
Duty Manager A and a receptionist work the early shift, and Duty Manager B and a receptionist work the late shift. All workers are entitled to have a 30-minute lunch break, but due to work pressures, this is rarely taken. Part of a duty manager’s job is to help out at reception; however, they are frequently drawn away to do other urgent tasks, leaving the receptionist on their own. At busy times this can cause long queues to form. Duty Manager B never leaves the site until at least 22:30 as they have to wait for everyone to leave before they can lock up the building for the night. Earlier this month, Duty Manager A was feeling very tired as they have been working long hours without any breaks. They began to lose their patience with members who were angry that they could not use some gym equipment because it is broken. The general manager heard about this outburst and was overheard telling Duty Manager A to "leave personal matters at home and concentrate on your work duties when you are at work." Duty Manager A subsequently went on sick leave, meaning that Duty Supervisor A had to temporarily cover their duties.
There is a maintenance supervisor with a team of three maintenance workers who are very busy. They are responsible for all of the facilities in the leisure centre, including gym equipment and monitoring the pool water, although specialist contractors are brought in when needed. Monitoring the pool water involves testing for chlorine levels, the pH of the water, and sending off samples for microbiological testing.
Duty Manager B is responsible for health and safety at WW. They want to take worker wellbeing seriously. To help inform their wellbeing strategy, they carried out a survey of workers’ wellbeing and developed the following strategic objectives:
prevent stress arising from customer interactions;
support workers in maintaining good physical health;
comply with workplace health and safety legislation and best practice;
promote a good work culture to support health and wellbeing.
Duty Manager B is currently arranging annual personal development review (PDR) meetings for all workers. A PDR looks at how workers have performed in the previous year, what they have achieved, and things that they can improve. There is also a discussion about whether any training or professional development is required, although there is a very small budget for this. Several workers have already completed a course about having difficult conversations. Workers have fixed-hours contracts, but may work overtime. Every month, workers must hand in a timesheet (a record of their hours worked). Duty managers review the timesheets to check working hours and overtime worked. This is to help ensure that workers are not working too many hours, and to check that there are no issues with the current shift patterns.
The incident
One busy afternoon, after standing in reception for 15 minutes under a light that keeps flashing on and off, a leisure centre member asks the receptionist on duty when the sauna will be working again. The receptionist informs them that the sauna will not be working for two weeks. The member becomes extremely angry and shouts at the receptionist in frustration, "This is completely unacceptable!" In their anger they throw their bag across the reception area, almost hitting a lifeguard in the process. The receptionist, who is working their third double shift (working two shifts back-to-back) in a row, also becomes angry, and replies, "You are just being silly, it is only a sauna!" This makes the member even angrier. They walk through the barrier, which has been left open because the leisure centre is so busy, go behind the reception desk and begin to physically threaten the receptionist. Duty Manager B sees what has happened and comes running over to offer support to the receptionist.
The receptionist is visibly upset. The duty manager knows that this is not the first time something like this has happened, so together they go to report this to the general manager. The general manager asks why they have not been told about previous incidents before, and the receptionist replies it is because they are always too busy and they do not know how to report such an incident.
Swimming pool maintenance
Chemicals are added to the swimming pool to control microbiological hazards. The main chemicals used at WW are sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) and hydrochloric acid 28% (HCl). These two chemicals are used in large quantities. NaOCl is a disinfectant, but also makes the swimming pool water more alkaline. HCl, a strong acid, is added to adjust for this. ‘pH’ is a measure of the acidity or alkalinity of the water; this is monitored and should be maintained in the range 7.2 to 7.4.
The NaOCl is stored in a 1 000-litre tank at one end of the plant room, and is delivered into the swimming pool water using an automatic dosing pump. Usually, the HCl is supplied in 20-litre containers and the minimum order that the supplier will send is 20 containers. These containers are delivered directly to the locked storeroom, next to the plant room, which is fitted with an internal bund. From here, the HCl is usually fed through pipes into the plant room and added into the swimming pool operating systems, again using an automatic metered pump attached to the 20-litre containers. Multiple containers are set up at the same time. Once one container is empty, the automatic system switches to the next container, thereby achieving a continuous supply to the swimming pool.
This constant adjusting of the pump flow rate means that the frequency with which containers of HCl need changing over is now less predictable. Therefore, the maintenance supervisor ordered the next batch of HCl as 45-litre containers instead, to arrive while they are on holiday. The containers will need changing less frequently and the HCl supply is less likely to run out, outside of working hours.
Wet changing room
It is a very busy afternoon at WW. A member has just come to reception and reported that a cleaner has slipped over in the wet changing rooms and are unable to get up off the floor. The receptionist looks around to find someone to help. There is no one around, so instead they try telephoning a few of their colleagues. Eventually, one of the lifeguards, who is not currently on duty at the swimming pool, answers the phone. They agree to check the wet changing room.
When the lifeguard arrives in the wet changing room, they find that the cleaner is now sitting on one of the benches surrounded by members attempting to help. One of the members says, "Oh, finally! You took your time!" The lifeguard messages the receptionist asking them to update the duty manager and to send for the maintenance supervisor.
Meanwhile, the receptionist has been very busy dealing with telephone calls and a queue of members coming into WW, so has not yet been able to contact the maintenance supervisor. Fortunately, the maintenance supervisor appears in the reception area to meet a contractor and is redirected to the changing room. By now, the area that the lifeguard had dried with the squeegee is wet again. The maintenance supervisor cannot find the wet floor sign in the cleaner’s cupboard and then remembers they were asked to order some new signs, as there is only one in the leisure centre. They mutter to themselves, "How many times have I told the management that they need to spend some money to get this drainage sorted properly?"
The next morning, when Duty Supervisor A arrives to open up WW, there is an angry note from the cleaners. They are complaining because it took three times longer than usual to clean the wet changing area yesterday evening, as dirt had dried onto the floor tiles. However, they do not mention anything about their colleague’s incident.
Spa pool
The spa pool at WW has separate operating equipment to the swimming pool, but still requires dosing with similar chemicals to those used for the swimming pool. The warm spa pool needs to be carefully monitored to reduce the risk of microbiological hazards. These hazards can arise due to bacterial growth, in particular, Legionella. Therefore, regular sampling and testing of the spa pool water is carried out to determine if the level of these bacteria is in line with acceptable standards.
The maintenance workers are responsible for taking the water samples, which are then sent to a laboratory for testing. Samples should be tested within 24 hours of being taken, so the contract with the laboratory requires the samples to be tested on the day they arrive. The maintenance supervisor keeps records of all previous results. Depending on the test result, they may need to adjust the disinfectant levels or pH. It is important to note the pH of the spa pool water, because as the pH of the water increases, the effectiveness of chlorine-based disinfectant in killing Legionella bacteria is reduced.
Supporting Documents
Safety data sheet hydrochloric acid 28%
Email to maintenance workers
Operational information for the spa pool
Waves and Weights organogram
Task 1: Use of chemicals to treat swimming pool water
1
Due to the leaking roof, the way in which hydrochloric acid (HCl) is used has temporarily needed to change.
(a) Explain what difference, if any, these changes have made to the risks associated with the use of hydrochloric acid at WW.
Note: You should support your answer using relevant information from the scenario and supporting documents 1 and 2 .
(b) What additional control measures could be introduced while these changes in the use of hydrochloric acid remain in place?
Note: You should support your answer using relevant information from the scenario and supporting documents 1 and 2 .
(30)
(16)
Task 2: Biological agents
2
(a) Explain how the spa pool at WW presents a risk of exposure to Legionella bacteria.
Note: You should support your answer, where applicable, using relevant information from the scenario and supporting document 3 .
(b) Explain what evidence suggests that the control of the risks of legionella may not be adequate.
Note: You should support your answer, where applicable, using relevant information from the scenario and supporting document 3 .
(c) In addition to the sampling and testing of spa pool water for legionella bacteria, what other control measures could be used to minimise the risk of exposure to legionella bacteria from the spa pool?
Note: You should support your answer, where applicable, using relevant information from the scenario and supporting document 3 .
(13)
(20)
(27)
Task 3: Work-related violence (WRV)
3
(a) The sauna being unavailable triggered the WRV incident described in the scenario.
Suggest what else could have contributed to this incident.
Note: Your answer must be based on the scenario only.
(b) What could WW do to reduce the risk of this WRV incident happening again?
Note: Your answer must relate directly to the scenario.
(c) What other factors in the leisure centre could contribute to WRV at WW?
Note: Your answer must be based on the scenario only.
(8)
( 16)
(8)
Task 4: Wellbeing strategy
4
(a) One of the WW wellbeing strategy objectives is ‘Prevent stress arising from customer interactions’.
(i) Comment on the appropriateness of this specific objective.Note: Your answer must be based on the scenario only.
(ii) Show how WW have failed to achieve this specific wellbeing strategy objective.Note: Your answer must be based on the scenario only.
(iii) Considering EACH of the other three wellbeing strategy objectives, what evidence is there to suggest these are not being fully achieved?Note: Your answer must be based on the scenario only.
(b) Review the evidence that suggests that worker wellbeing is positively addressed at WW.
Note: Your answer must be based on the scenario only.
(5)
(10)
(10)
(12)
End of assessment
For NEBOSH Learners : DN2 - DI2 answers . 100% AI-Free, plagiarism-free 96% pass rate
Order this Assignment Now: £299
Email: care@academiasupport.co.uk
100% Plagiarism Free & Custom Written, Tailored to your instructions